I had a conversation recently with a friend whose friendship means more to me than any friendship I have ever had. God has shown me why that is, and part of the why is this. He has given me a teaching gift, and He built this friendship, in part, to be a place where that gift gets to move. The wisdom to use that gift did not come from a classroom. The wisdom came from experience, the classroom just helped me put it into words.
It came from years of caregiving that stripped me down to what actually holds a person together and what does not. It came from health battles that forced me to feel things I could not outrun or explain away. It came from relationships where my own emotions nearly wrecked me before I understood them, and from choosing, again and again, not to stay confused, but to bring every bit of it to God and ask Him to show me what was actually happening underneath what I felt.
This wisdom is hard won. It cost me things, including the death and rebirth of myself, more than once. And that is exactly why I recognize it when I see someone else standing in the same confusion I once stood in. But even gifts get knocked off balance when emotion enters the room, and it is easy for emotion to enter the room with someone you love that much. That is exactly what happened.
We were talking about feelings. She sees it simply. The devil sits on one side offering misery, God sits on the other offering good, and you choose which one you live in. I pushed back. I told her that is not how it works, that you do not choose how you feel about something, you only choose what you do with the feeling once it arrives. She did not hear it the way I meant it. She felt argued with rather than loved, and that sat heavy on me long after we hung up.
Not being interested in being right or wrong, but in understanding what God was trying to clarify, I took it to prayer. Something in me knew there was more to say than I had managed to say in the moment, and I wanted God to show me what it was. He did. He showed me that this is not just a disagreement between two friends. It is one of the most common misunderstandings among people who have not yet gone deep into the inner landscape of themselves, the ones who have not yet learned to tell the difference between what a feeling is and where a feeling came from.
God showed me that this post is not really about that one conversation. It is the offering of a tool — something anyone can pick up and use to finally understand how this actually works, in themselves, in their walk, in the war they are already standing in whether they know it or not.
The Shoulder Analogy We Were All Handed
Most of us were raised on the same picture whether we grew up in church or not. An angel on one shoulder, a devil on the other, and a person in the middle choosing which voice to obey. It is not untrue. There is a real enemy and there is a real God and there is a real choice being made in every human heart every day. But the picture is incomplete, and the place it breaks down is exactly where my friend and I broke down.
The picture we see in cartoons and in memes teaches us to sort everything into two piles: positive and negative. It teaches us to believe that whichever pile we feel ourselves standing in tells us which side we have chosen. Feel good, must be God. Feel bad, must be the devil. Choose your feelings, choose your side.
That is not what scripture teaches. It is not how the enemy actually operates. It is why discernment is SO important, and the only way to develop and to employ discernment is to have a living, active, and true relationship with the source of it: God, through the Holy Spirit.
Part of what makes the shoulder framework so easy to fall into is that most of us were only ever given a handful of words for what we feel. Happy. Sad. Mad. Glad. Excited. Scared. As if the entire landscape of human feeling could be sorted into a short list of primary colors. But feelings are not that simple, and they were never meant to be.
It also matters which part of you is managing a given feeling. Ego manages a feeling by asking what protects me, what proves me right, what gets me out of this discomfort fastest. Heart manages the same feeling by asking what is true, and what love requires, placing self-importance and self-fulfillment last, putting God first. The same ache, the same anger, the same grief can be handed to either one, and which one takes it determines whether it grows you or shrinks you.
Consider grief as an example. There is the ache of missing someone who is still alive, a holy grief that keeps you tender toward what matters, and there is a grief that curdles into resentment toward the very people you love. There is relief tangled up in that same grief too, the relief of surrender to what God has allowed, or the relief of simply wanting the discomfort to end regardless of what it cost someone else.
The same is true of anger, peace, and joy. There is anger that is not righteous, only fear wearing a louder coat, as opposed to anger that rises in defense of what is holy. There is peace that is really numbness wearing a calmer coat, as opposed to the peace that passeth understanding, which stays present and alert even in the storm. And there is joy that coexists with sorrow in the very same breath, the way it must have for Christ Himself in the garden, both willing and grieved in the same moment, and joy that flees the moment sorrow shows up at all, unable to hold both because it was never rooted in anything deeper than circumstance.
If you try to sort a landscape that wide into only two piles, positive and negative, instead of fully experiencing your feelings, learning the reality of them and understanding what they truly are and how they affect you, you will misfile most of what you actually feel, and you will misjudge where it came from every time.
The Angel of Light
The most important reality to clarify regarding any of this is the truth about the devil. If the devil only ever offered misery, no one would ever choose him. He knows this better than we do. The truth is that the devil will use your misunderstanding of “feelings” against you, to destroy you. That is his entire MO. Scripture tells us plainly what he actually looks like when he is working.
For Satan himself is transformed into an angel of light. (2 Corinthians 11:14)
The devil does not come advertising himself as darkness. He comes wearing the shape of something that feels good, feels peaceful, feels loving, feels right. False comfort that tells you not to examine yourself. False peace that tells you avoidance is healing. A love that feels warm but is leading you away from what is holy. He is not slower than a human manipulator. He is faster, and one of his fastest tools is a positive feeling wrapped around an unrighteous thing.
This is why sorting by feeling will always fail you. He is not trying to feel bad to you. He is trying to feel good enough that you stop asking where it came from. He is trying to trick you into believing you are feeling, and following, God.
Where the Energy Actually Comes From
There is a piece of this that God has been unfolding in me for a while now, and it belongs in this post because it sits underneath everything else I am saying. The world talks constantly about energy. Good energy, bad energy, vibration, frequency, alignment, manifestation, the Universe giving and taking. People treat this language as though it belongs to the world, as though it was invented outside of God and Christians have to decide whether to borrow it or reject it.
The word “energy” is not the world’s word. It is God’s creation, wearing a name the world gave it because the world does not know whose it is. God IS energy.
For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead. (Romans 1:20)
Every real thing a person has ever sensed moving through them, through a room, through a moment of connection or unease, is something God built into creation before the world ever had language for it. The world did not discover energy on its own. It brushed up against something God made, felt that it was real, and then built a whole framework around it with Him left out. That is the pattern behind every counterfeit spirituality. Take something true that belongs to God, strip the Person out of it, and repackage it as a force to manage instead of a Father to know.
Paul stood in front of people who already had their own spiritual framework and did not tell them their sense of something greater was fake.
For in him we live, and move, and have our being. (Acts 17:28)
He redirected them. He told them the thing they already sensed was real, and then He told them who it actually belonged to. That is the move for us too. It is not to reject what a person feels moving through them, but to ask them, and to ask ourselves, whose it actually is.
This matters for the feelings conversation because it means feelings themselves are not the battlefield. The battlefield is discernment. Can you tell the difference between something real that belongs to God and something real that the enemy has gotten his hands on first.
Negative Is Not the Same As Wrong
Once you understand that the devil can hand you something that feels wonderful but is actually danger in disguise, the next piece falls into place easily. God can hand you something that feels terrible. Anger is not only a perfect example; it is the most common one.
Be ye angry, and sin not. (Ephesians 4:26)
Anger is not sin. Scripture assumes there is a righteous version of it and commands you to stay inside that version rather than commanding you to never feel it. Jesus felt it in the temple. The prophets felt it constantly. Righteous anger is a response to what is unholy, and a person who never feels it in the presence of real evil is not more spiritual, they are less awake.
Unrighteous anger is different in its root, not just in its volume. Righteous anger rises up in defense of what is holy. Unrighteous anger rises up in defense of self, of ego, of what you feel you are owed or what you feel has been taken from you. It is not protecting truth, it is protecting pride, and pride dressed up as righteous conviction is one of the enemy’s favorite disguises. This is the anger that lingers long after the offense has passed, that rehearses the wrong on repeat, that would rather stay armed than be healed. It does not defend, it destroys, and the first thing it destroys is your own joy, because a heart occupied with unrighteous anger has no room left in it to receive peace even when peace is offered.
Let all bitterness, and wrath, and anger, and clamour, and evil speaking, be put away from you, with all malice. (Ephesians 4:31)
Scripture does not lump this in with the anger it commands you to hold onto without sin. This is the anger it commands you to put away entirely, because this is the anger that does not answer to God, it answers to the wound. It answers to the ego. It will masquerade as strength. It will masquerade as standing your ground. But underneath it is almost always fear, or hurt, or a self that has decided protecting itself matters more than being transformed. That is why it steals joy so efficiently. Joy requires an open hand. Unrighteous anger requires a closed fist, and you cannot hold both at once.
Another example of a feeling that is not negative, but is often labeled as such, is sorrow.
For godly sorrow worketh repentance to salvation not to be repented of: but the sorrow of the world worketh death. (2 Corinthians 7:10)
Two people can cry the exact same tears and be in two entirely different places with God. One grief turns a person toward repentance and toward Him. The other grief turns a person further in on themselves until it becomes its own kind of death. The feeling looked the same from the outside. The fruit was nothing alike.
This is why the “devil on one shoulder, God on the other” framework cannot hold up under scripture. Good and bad feelings are not the sorting mechanism. Righteous and unrighteous is the sorting mechanism, and righteousness can wear a feeling that looks and feels negative just as easily as unrighteousness can wear one that looks and feels positive.
Testing What You Feel
There is a way which seemeth right unto a man, but the end thereof are the ways of death. (Proverbs 14:12)
Feeling right and being right have never been the same test in scripture, and that verse alone should end the idea that a feeling can be trusted simply because it arrived wearing peace or certainty.
Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world. (1 John 4:1)
This is the actual instruction we have been given. Not choose the positive feeling over the negative one. Try it. Test it. Ask where it came from and where it is leading — understand both. That is discernment, and discernment is a discipline, not a mood.
What You Are Actually Choosing
So if you do not get to choose how a feeling arrives, or when, what do you get to choose?
And be not conformed to this world: but be ye transformed by the renewing of your mind. (Romans 12:2)
It is absolutely true that human beings can make choices about their feelings, but whether or not to feel them is not one of those choices. This is why understanding how feelings actually operate in your body is so important. A feeling is a natural, automatic, and not always conscious physiological experience.
Think of it much like blinking your eyes. You sometimes choose to blink consciously, but the majority of your blinks each day happen without you ever noticing or consciously realizing it. A feeling rises in the body before it ever passes through the mind, which is exactly why you cannot reason your way out of one the moment it arrives, and exactly why you cannot simply decide not to have it.
You choose what you do with a feeling once it is here. Shutting it down is simply not one of those choices, because even if you are not consciously aware of it the feeling is still present in your body and affecting you. You choose whether you let it renew your mind toward Him or whether you let it conform you further to whatever pattern the world or the enemy handed it to you in. You choose whether you flow with it unexamined or whether you bring it into the light and ask God to show you its source.
But strong meat belongeth to them that are of full age, even those who by reason of use have their senses exercised to discern both good and evil. (Hebrews 5:14)
Discernment is trained. It is developed. It is not a switch you flip once. It is a sense you exercise the way you would exercise anything else God has given you the capacity to grow, and that growth is an ongoing process, refined by Him in us throughout our lives.
Ego and Heart
This is where the conversation I described to you with my friend actually lives, underneath the theology. It matters which part of a person is showing up to the conversation. Ego shows up when winning is the most important thing to a person. It argues, because it wants to win. Heart shows up when healing is the most important thing to a person. It speaks, because it wants to heal something — even if that means admitting ego was wrong. That is a very important distinction to hold and understand.
It did not come across this way to my friend, but I was not trying to win. I was trying to hand her something true because I love her enough to risk the conversation feeling uncomfortable rather than let her keep standing on a framework I know, from personal experience, will eventually fail her in a moment that matters.
But speaking the truth in love, may grow up into him in all things, which is the head, even Christ. (Ephesians 4:15)
Once the truth has been spoken, ego and heart part ways again. Ego cannot let go. It needs to be proven right and needs the other person to know it in that moment. Heart can let go, because it already gave what it came to give, and it trusts God with whatever happens after. I intended to operate from, and believe I was operating from, the heart posture, even if it did not land that way. The truth is always kind, even when it is not received as kindness, and I have had to make peace with the fact that those two things are not always going to look the same from where the other person is standing.
A Tool, Not Just a Story
If you walk away from this post with one thing, let it be this. Stop sorting your life by what feels good and what feels bad. Start sorting it by what is righteous and what is not, by what belongs to God and what the enemy has only borrowed the shine of.
Remember that the devil is sneaky, and intentionally so. He shows up as something that appears good because he does not want to be rejected. He intentionally shows up wearing the angel of light costume this whole post has been describing, and the only way to see past the costume is to already know who he really is underneath it. Study him the way you study God, not to admire him, but to recognize him. Know his tactics so well that the shine does not fool you the next time he wears something beautiful.
That is the discernment scripture actually calls you to, and it is available to you the same way it became available to me, on your knees, asking Him to show you what you could not see on your own.
Selah.
One thought on “The Truth About Your Feelings | Daily Bread”
Comments are closed.